I am a huge fan of George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire (ASOIAF). I’ve read the main novels multiple times, devoured Fire & Blood, and re-watched the various television series multiple times as well. Across the five published books, the companion volumes, and the broader history of Westeros, Martin has given us an incredible roster of warriors: shining paragons of knighthood, cunning tacticians, and downright devious (or monstrous) fighters.
Back in 2011, before the release of A Dance with Dragons, I originally compiled a Top 10 list of the greatest warriors in Westeros (see the orginal list below). With new material and years of additional perspective, it was clear the rankings needed a thorough revision. Some positions have shifted, a few names dropped off, and the list has now expanded to a full Top 20.
What follows is my current, updated ranking—part tribute, part analysis, and entirely my own opinion. Rankings are based on a mix of demonstrated skill, battlefield reputation, leadership, and overall impact within the world of ice and fire.
What Matters in This Ranking
- Warrior Ability First — Raw combat skill, proven feats, and battlefield effectiveness take priority. (Note: “Best knight” in the chivalric sense and “best warrior” are not always the same thing, as the Red Viper clearly demonstrates.)
- Prime Condition — Characters are judged at their peak, not in their current or declining state.
- Books Take Precedence — The novels are the primary canon. The television show is secondary. When both align (e.g., Ser Arthur Dayne), it strengthens the case. When they diverge (e.g., Brienne of Tarth), the books win. Example: Brienne is one of the strongest fighters in the current timeline, but her book feats (including nearly dying to Biter) keep her from ranking higher. The show version becomes somewhat inflated in later seasons.
- Reputation + Results — What other characters say about them, combined with what they have actually accomplished.
Note on Leadership: While this ranking focuses primarily on individual warrior ability and combat prowess, leadership is used as a secondary tiebreaker when two warriors are otherwise close. Ser Arthur Dayne needs no help here—his reputation stands on pure skill. For something like Jaime Lannister versus Barristan Selmy, Jaime earns a slight edge due to his battlefield command experience. Robert Baratheon’s leadership during Robert’s Rebellion (ultimately winning a kingdom) boosts him significantly. The same logic applies elsewhere when feats are nearly equal.
So with all that said here are the new updated rankings. It's also important to note the tie at #3. The daylight between the two is so small in my opinion its near impossible to say one is better than the other.
![]() |
| Map of Westeros by Arwo1f can be found here |
Twenty Greatest Warriors of Westeros
1. Ser Arthur Dayne, The Sword of the Morning - Untouchable #1. Near-universal consensus as the greatest knight Westeros has ever seen.
2. Oberyn Martell, The Red
Viper of Dorne - His fight with the Mountain alone and overall
deadliness justify it.
3A. Ser Jamie Lannister, The
Kingslayer - Perhaps the greatest natural talent and
prodigy of his generation.
3B. Ser Barristan Selmy, The Bold, - Lord Commander of the Kingsguard - All-time great. Legendary longevity and skill.
5. Daemon Blackfyre - The Black Dragon. Fire & Blood confirms his strength as a warrior and leader.
6. Aemon the Dragonknight - Legendary Targaryen hero. One of the most revered knights in history.
7. Robert Baratheon - An absolute monster in his prime during Robert’s Rebellion.
8. Sandor Clegane, TheHound - Fearsome size, skill, and surprising conscience make him a standout.
9. Gregor Clegane, The Mountain - Brutal strength and terror personified. Westeros’ most monstrous fighter.
10. Daemon Targaryen, The Rogue Prince - Charismatic, daring, and exceptionally skilled in battle.
11. Victarion Greyjoy -Ironborn brute force and veteran of countless raids and battles
12. Bronn - The smartest fighter on the list. Survives by knowing exactly when and how to fight.
13. Brynden Tully, The Blackfish - Uncompromising defender of Riverrun and one of the most respected knights alive.
14. Garlan Tyrell - Skilled and often underrated warrior of the Reach.
15. Gerold Hightower, The White Bull, Lord Commander of the Kingsguard - Tower of the Joy legend.
16. Rheagar Targaryen - The Prince of Dragonstone. Warrior-poet with immense talent.
17. Mance Rayder - King-Beyond-the-Wall. Battle-hardened leader of the Free Folk
18. Jon Snow - Rising force with proven skill, leadership, and resilience.
19. Qhorin Halfhand - Elite ranger of the Night’s Watch. Legendary among the brothers.
20. Brienne of Tarth - One of the strongest current-timeline fighters, despite some early setbacks.
In time I'll be reviewing all of them fully and adding the links back here. Part of the fun of this its all
For the sake of completeness the original list from 2011 was as follows. In all cases I've gone back and repurposed the exiting entries and updated rather than leave them as is. I did this to avoid confusion of having two sets of posts for the same character on the blog.
1. Ser Arthur Dayne, The Sword of the Morning
2. The Red Viper of Dorne
3. Ser Jamie Lannister, The King Slayer
4. Ser Barristan Selmy, Lord Commander of the Kingsguard
5. Sandor Clegane, The Hound
6. Syrio Forel
7. Gregor Clegane, The Mountain
8. Robert Baratheon
9. Bronn
10. Brynden Tully, The Blackfish
There you have it, the old list for historical purposes with the new updated ranking above. Opinions can (and will) be made as to why one warrior is better than another, but there can be some informed debate by reading the text closely and with the added bonus of the television show when it matches the character depicted.
Let me know your thoughts.




